Something in the world of floating have you stumped?
Show Highlights
What the heck are double stud walls and why would I need them?
Graham and Ashkahn talk about this and how a high level of soundproofing and construction design can make the difference between a perfectly quiet float, and one where you can hear the person chanting and doing yoga in the room next to you and trucks rumbling by outside.
When it comes to float centers, what’s inside the walls is what makes the experiences outside them so special.
Show Resources
Listen to Just the Audio
Transcription of this episode… (in case you prefer reading)
Graham: Today’s question, from one of our listeners is, What the heck are double-stud walls and why should I use them?
Ashkahn: Oh, okay. I was hoping we’d get away with that, talking about why they’re used at all, but they had to sneak that in there, huh?
Graham: Yeah, because the “what” is really the easy part of the question.
Ashkahn: Yeah, it’s two sets of studs in a wall.
Graham: I don’t know actually how to describe it much better than that, except you have actually two sets of base studs or the base plates, two top plates, and you have two rows of studs that make up your wall with an air gap in between them, which can usually be anything from an inch up to a foot or so.
Ashkahn: It’s basically like two walls, like you just have a wall right next to another wall, is what a double-stud wall is.
Graham: As opposed to a single set of studs with the walling material on both sides of that, which would be a single-stud wall.
Ashkahn: Why you use them almost feels like the better part to start with, because they sound really weird without knowing why you’d ever build something like that.
Graham: That takes twice as many materials, twice as much labor.
Ashkahn: Like, “I already have a wall. Why would I build another wall?”
Graham: The reason that you want them is that they help a lot with soundproofing. One of the core parts of soundproofing your float center, and any room that you want to soundproof really, is to have some kind of air gap built into the wall. You can accomplish that through a couple different means.
You can also have a clip and channel system, where you actually attach these clips to a single-stud wall and have some channels you run through there and then put your drywall material onto those channels, and that creates an air gap as well. I won’t go into that too much. You can look it up if you want to see diagrams. It should make a lot more sense than listening to my voice over the air.
For the double-stud wall, it’s actually much more understandable. Those two studs are not connected, and so once you have the sound waves hitting one side of the wall, the material on one side, they’re not just transmitted directly through the studs to the other side of the wall and then out. They hit that wall material and then they have to go through this air gap before they hit the material on the other side and then come out. It turns out that just that transition between solid, air, and back to solid again, is what accomplishes a huge amount of your soundproofing in your rooms.
Ashkahn: The more of an air gap you have in between there, the better it tends to do with soundproofing, so as the sound travels and hits that wall, it gets into that air space in between and it’s basically resonating through that air space. What happens is when you set those two walls further apart from each other, you’re making that air space larger, and as a result you’re making the frequency that it resonates at, which is the most likely or the easiest frequency of sound that can travel through that medium.
You’re making that go lower and lower. The lower you can get it, the better it tends to be for human ears. Our human ears have more trouble detecting it when it’s in those lower ranges than the higher ranges around the human voice and stuff like that. Having that larger sound gap tends to be better soundproofing.
Graham: Similarly with that, because that frequency is specific, we’ve also heard, although we haven’t played around with it much ourselves, that actually skewing the walls a little bit so they’re offset on an angle by a few inches so they’re not totally straight will further increase the cost of your construction, first of all, because not only are you building two sets of studs, now you have to do some crazy scribing on the ceilings because your walls aren’t actually parallel to each other.
Theoretically, that will actually even cut down on that resonant frequency that’s bouncing around in there, because you don’t have one flat plane in front of another, and cut down on the reverberation bouncing back and forth between them as well. That’s something else that can help with that effect. Another question that the listener didn’t ask but which I’d like to ask for them is if double studs are awesome, why not use triple studs or even a quadruple-stud setup?
It turns out in the case of having three sets of studs or sometimes more commonly two studs but you’ve covered both sides of one stud with wall material and both sides of the other stud with wall materials, now you have four times as many or twice as many sheets of walling up there.
There’s names for those. The amount of walls that you have up is called the leaves, is the actual sheets that you have. If, in a double-stud setup, only the outside of either of your studs is covered, that’s two leaves that you have there. If you were to cover, then, the inside as well, that makes it four leaves. Or if you had three sets of studs and only one side of each of them, that would be a triple-leaf system.
Ashkahn: These are actually generally regarded as worse soundproofing than what you could do with the same material were you to just have two leaves, so if you’re using the same amount of lumber and the same amount of drywall and all of that, it’s actually best to just have a solid chunk on the outsides and a big air gap in the middle.
That goes back to that resonant frequency of the air. As soon as you’re cutting that giant air gap into two small air gaps, because now you have a leaf in the middle or a wall in the middle, now you’re making two smaller bodies of air that can, again, resonate at those higher frequencies rather than the lower ones.
For the same cost, for the same amount of materials, and for the same space that it takes up, you generally are best off with as much material on the outsides as possible and as big of an air gap in the inside as possible.
Graham: Yep. To the point where you can use the exact same amount of material and just by switching two of the leaves to the inside of the wall as opposed to all of them being on the outside, you can cut the soundproofing in a quarter, so you’re now being a quarter as effective in your soundproofing just by rearranging the material instead of having that single big air gap.
Ashkahn: The last part of all this is that you want to reduce the amount of resonance once the sound is inside those walls as much as possible, too. That’s where this soundproofing insulation comes from.
While it seems like soundproofing insulation is something that’s going to stop sound from going through, it’s actually much more there to dampen sound on the inside of walls so when sound gets in, instead of bouncing back and forth wildly between your two sets of drywall, there’s sound like rockwool type of material specifically sound-absorbent insulation in there that is meant to dampen it and catch it so that you don’t create this kind of drum-like resonant body inside of your walls. Or as I like to say, guitar-like resonant frequency inside the walls.
Graham: That’s why people use double-stud walls.
Ashkahn: Yeah, good. Solid.
Graham: You think?
Ashkahn: Double solid.
Graham: Thanks for tuning in. We’ll see you tomorrow.
Recent Podcast Episodes
Does it matter how you order your filtration equipment on a float tank? – DSP 155
When setting up your float tank, it can be tempting to look at the spa pack and imagine how much more convenient it would be if the pieces were rearranged a little bit. So… is there a particular order to the filtration equipment? Why or why not?
Fortunately, Graham and Ashkahn have painfully researched this issue and know all the ins and outs of water treatment systems for float tanks and why they are the way they are.
Pairing Psychotherapy and Floats – DSP 154
It’s easy to look at some of the research that comes from floating or look at special programs for veterans with PTSD and think about how float tanks should be paired with psychotherapy.
Graham and Ashkahn have met several therapists who use float tanks in conjunction with their sessions, sometimes exclusively. They also know that it’s important to recognize that they are trained professionals who are providing a treatment for difficult to treat psychological issues in some cases. Knowing when to leave the work to the experts is a valuable part of providing a service like this one with so many broad uses.
What is too small for a 4-tank float center? – DSP 153
Real estate costs from building out a float center, especially in an urban area, can get costly really quick. Sometimes compromises need to be made. But how much of a compromise is too compromised?
As with the best float center mistakes, Graham and Ashkahn can speak to their personal experience on this issue. They talk about opening a four tank center with less than 1,000 square feet and how much of a mistake it is. They also provide helpful planning tips so you can find out how much space you need at an absolute minimum for your float center.
How Do You Find Time for Hobbies? (Rise) – DSP 152
This is the last episode we recorded at Rise and it seemed fitting to close out the recordings with the organizers again, Jake and Kevin. In this episode they talk with Graham and Ashkahn to answer a question from Greg Griffin about how to manage your time after opening a float center to dedicate to hobbies.
While the episode starts a little heavy, the conversation turns and begins discussing the value of work and how rewarding it is to be in this industry.
Thank you to everyone who came and talked to us at Rise and shared your experiences. If we don’t see you at the Float Conference, hopefully we’ll see you next year. As always, float on.
What’s the Weirdest Post Float Experience You’ve Seen (Rise) – DSP 151
Another conversation that was captured at Rise was this little sit down between Graham and Ashkahn and a float center owner by the name of Jeremy out in San Antonio. They talk about a subject that I think comes up whenever float people get together. “What’s the weirdest thing you’ve seen after someone got out of a float?”
Sometimes people have a hard time coming back to Earth after a really good session in the tank and seeing how they interact with the rest of the world afterwards can be heartwarming and enlightening. It’s part of the reason we do what we do.
Latest Blog Posts
Thou Shall Not Program
Floating is on the rise, and this means there are lots of new faces trying floating out for the first time. When someone comes to you for their first time, what should you say to explain floating? Just as importantly, is there anything you should avoid saying? Or...
How to Clean and Maintain Your Float Tank – An Owner’s Guide
This post is kept around for historical purposes, but doesn't reflect our current knowledge of float tank sanitation. Please see The Basics of Float Tank Sanitation and Testing and Maintaining Float Tank Water Quality instead. Ashkahn and I just got back from...
Meditations on Mediation
I just had to mediate a discussion between two of my employees, and I couldn’t be happier. Neither of them is going to lose their job: we’ve never fired an employee. Neither of them is going to be paid more or less than the other: we pay all of our employees the same....
From ‘I’m never doing this’ to ‘when can I sign up?’ in 30 seconds
When you show people the float tanks, inevitably some of your potential customers will be freaked out. That's fine, it's normal, it's how people reacted to Rock n' Roll. Now, you need to know upfront that there's a small group of people who will, in fact, never be...
