Something in the world of floating have you stumped?
Show Highlights
James Nestor, a science-adventure journalist with a focus on reporting about humans relationship to water. He is speaking at the Conference this year and Ashkahn took the time to ask him about some of the research John Lilly did on dolphin communication back in the day. He shares cool stories about Lilly’s work at that time as well as the impacts it’s had throughout the scientific community since.
Show Resources
Listen to Just the Audio
Transcription of this episode… (in case you prefer reading)
Ashkahn: Hey everybody, this is Ashkahn here. We have a slightly different episode for you guys today. Instead of doing our normal thing of answering questions, I am here with one of our Float Conference speakers, James Nestor. We just did an interview over on our Float Conference Podcast and we thought we’d ask one more little bonus fun question to air here on Daily Solutions. Okay James, welcome to our Daily Solutions Podcast. Thanks for hopping on here.
James: Thanks for having me.
Ashkahn: Yes, so we just did an interview over for Float Conference POdcast, but I had kind of one other question for you that I thought would be fun to air here. You had done this work in your book about freediving and like we discussed, you’d come across John Lilly in this kind of other direction, not through the lens of floating, but through the lens of his dolphin research which arguably I think he’s almost better known for at least in certain many circles than any of his float tank stuff. In the float industry, we get to hear a lot of cool stories about John Lilly and float tanks and know a lot about that history and I was just wondering if you came across any interesting John Lilly dolphin stories in your research that you think would be fun to share.
James: Oh, there’s too many. But one in particular I thought was pretty fascinating was when he had set up the communications research project in the Bahamas. This was a sweeping laboratory, huge, with different tools and different rooms and all the modern technology at the time. He built this dolphin telephone system that allowed two dolphins to talk to one another in separate tanks across the laboratory and it was very interesting because dolphins have two different modes of communication. They have these whistles and these buzzes, they’re called clicks and so the animals would have these interactions and he recorded them and he found what he thought was two different completely formed languages.
One, that they could hold these simultaneous conversations on these two different frequencies and they would never ever talk over one another. It got to the point when he started getting really nervous, I think this is one of the reasons that he shut down that whole program, was when every time he would press the recorder, the dolphins would talk a bit and stop and they would stop at the same exact time and he was certain that they knew when he was recording and when he was eavesdropping on them and he started to think that perhaps they were plotting their escape. What’s really interesting about his research is the early stuff he was doing, all of it was published in the top scientific journals at the time. These things were published in Science and the Nature.
He was really considered the preeminent dolphin communication researcher and it’s only later in his years when you started doing some more wacky stuff that that reputation was a bit stained. But all of that early work is phenomenal and to me it’s the most interesting interspecies communication research that I’ve ever come across.
Ashkahn: Yeah. Still surprisingly referenced, I mean, I went and saw a talk from a current dolphin researcher a few years ago. There’s like a little guest lecturer here in Portland and like she was referencing John Lilly’s work and it’s still a big part of that entire field of research. It really didn’t seem like a huge piece of the foundation for all of that.
James: Yeah. It’s kind of sad that so much of that communication research both went away and went underground. The Navy has been doing tons of it. They continue to do dolphin communication research. We just don’t have access to it. So maybe they’ve carried on where Lilly left off and they’ve continued to develop this but I don’t think we’ll ever know. He was just at a place in time where he had money, he had equipment, he had all the resources he needed and very few ethical quandaries in his research to just do whatever he wanted to do. That was both good and bad. It was bad for dolphins because a few of them committed suicide in his presence because they were so miserable, but scientifically speaking, it’s provided a foundation upon which so many researchers have built their own communication research initiatives.
Ashkahn: Yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah, definitely, near the end of his life. One of my favorite John Lilly stories is him trying to form the Cetacean nation and actually have a seat for Cetaceans in the United Nations to give them rights which-
James: Yeah. I mean, I love it. I love that idea, but this is the sort of stuff that really put dolphin communication research in the trash bin for awhile, at least in academic institutions because Lilly was trying to figure out how to televise dolphin ballets and dolphin pop songs. When scientists heard that they just kind of threw out all of his research and luckily now people have gone back through it and have looked at that early stuff and realized just how groundbreaking and legit it actually was.
Ashkahn: Yeah, I bet it was surprising for him too. I mean, there’s like a section in Programming and Metaprogramming, his book, one of his earlier books where he’s doing some of his early dolphin research and there’s a chapter in there that’s literally just a plea from him to the scientific community to have other people researching this. That’s like the whole chapter is just him being like, “This, there’s some crazy stuff going on here and more people need to be researching dolphins and dolphin communication,” and it was him just like trying to get that out there. So, at the very least it’s been nice to see that that work has continued. I mean there’s definitely some ongoing continuing dolphin research, especially around communication that’s been happening and proving really, really interesting. I don’t know. Everything I read about it shows a kind of development of language that we don’t usually see in other areas of the animal kingdom.
James: Yeah, that’s exactly right. He was a true scientist in that sense where science is supposed to be the exploration of the unknown. Other people are supposed to to test this stuff and for people to make up their minds and make assumptions about things that they’ve never tested, I think is just so ridiculous. It was part of this that got me personally so interested in Cetacean communication and I’m working with David Gruber now who’s a Harvard fellow and we have put together and it’s mostly him, he’s doing all of the academic work here. We’re now looking at all of these huge database of sperm whale clicks and using machine learning algorithms to try to crack into the whatever language code is within there and we’re hoping in the next six months, we’re building a machine right now and we’re going to probably go into the Mediterranean to record cliques in a fidelity that they’ve never been recorded before and then to try to figure out what these animals are saying with the AI and machine learning.
What’s amazing is I’m a journalist, right? I’m not a biologist. I’m not a scientist, like what business do I have doing this? But the fact is nobody else is doing it. There’s so much technology now that we have that Lilly did not have that can make all of these translation automatic, you put it in computer, come back the next morning and it’s all figured out and nobody’s doing it. I just find that that’s pretty offensive, but we’re really excited. The one good thing about it is the reaction we’ve gotten from some of the top guys at Harvard and MIT, real engineers and scientists who have looked at these clicks and are just saying obviously there’s something very profound and interesting going on here. Hopefully soon we’ll be able to tell everybody what that is.
Ashkahn: Yeah. Very cool. Yeah, we’ll to check back in in six months and hear what the results are.
James: I’ll be speaking dolphin by then so maybe we could have the conversation that way.
Ashkahn: Awesome. Okay, great. Thanks so much, James. Nice to have you on here and excited to see you at the conference in just about a month.
James: Thank you. See you soon.
Ashkahn: All right. If you guys out there have more float tank questions that you want us to answer here, you can always send them into us at floattanksolutions.com/podcast. If you want to hear a longer interview with James Nestor, you can hop over to our Float Conference Podcast, that’s at floatconference.com. I will talk to you guys tomorrow.
Recent Podcast Episodes
Are Tankless Water Heaters the Best? – DSP 270
Graham and Jake take on talking about Tankless or “On Demand” water heaters today. They break down a lot of the benefits of them compared to storage water heaters like the fact that they provide a nearly limitless source of hot water, require less energy consumption, etc. They’re not perfect though, and any float center considering one should look closely on how best to implement them. Jake shares some of the pitfalls of them as well as how to maximize their usefulness.
Should Float Centers use Light or Heavy Gauge Studs? – DSP 269
Still no Ashkahn today. He’s taking a couple of post-conference days to himself.
Jake and Graham are on the scene though to answer construction questions, though. Even the straight forward ones, like today. Jake informs us which to choose when doing construction, light or heavy gauge studs when constructing a float center, while getting a little sidetracked when comparing wooden and metal studs.
Construction to Make Your Life Easier – DSP 268
Graham and Jake cover a wide range of construction tips to make running a float center easier. Everything from making sure you have extra storage to installing mop closets with sinks in them for dealing with heavy duty chemicals.
The advice is pretty much a shotgun approach of tips, tricks, and hard lessons learned throughout the years.
Draining Float Tanks into Septic Systems – DSP 267
Graham and Jake tackle the difficulties of draining float tanks and how that process can differ based on different municipalities, different water treatment systems, or whether you’re using a septic system or not.
Water treatment typically involves whole contained ecosystems and highly concentrated epsom salt water can impact that pretty drastically. The guys provide good tips for each type of system and what to be prepared for if you’re operating in a rural area with a septic system.
The Difference Between STC and Decibels – DSP 266
Post-Conference Ashkahn is still out of the recording studio, but fortunately Jake is keeping Graham company in there.
Graham and Jake break down the differences between decibels and STC ratings, two very important to understand when figuring out soundproofing. There’s a lot to digest in this episode, but fortunately the guys keep it easy to understand by providing a broad level overview of the different concepts.
Latest Blog Posts
The Float Tour Blog – Issue #28
Home sweet home! After so many months on the road, it was strange being back here in Portland. We were exhausted, excited, and a little travel weary. The first night back, I slept in my own bed for the first time in three months and the world just melted away.
Having travelled across the United States, I’m reminded of how insular Portland is. We are aggressively fixated on keeping things local. Local beer, ketchup, bikes, pet food, pillows, phone cases… it’s part of our charm. We want to reward people for living here and being a part of the community. It’s so pervasive that, after living here for so long, I kind of forgot that Secret Aardvark hot-sauce isn’t available everywhere, and that most cities don’t even recycle, let alone compost.
The Float Tour Blog – Issue #27
Our northern neighbor – a sister city, of sorts – Seattle is the largest metropolitan area in the Pacific Northwest. It’s the land of Microsoft and Kurt Cobain, and the culture here embraces both simultaneously. It’s tech business professional in the front and rock n’ roll grunge in the back. This blend creates a perfect storm of high energy business life and high energy nightlife, making relaxation a valuable commodity. Floating helps fill the void left by nightmarish traffic and overcrowded restaurants.
Given that it’s so close to home, the float centers in Seattle are a lot more familiar to us. Our visits here were more like a high school reunion than they were like the first day of school. During some of our visits, we were picking up conversations right where we left them.
The Float Tour Blog Issue #26
Vancouver is the largest metropolitan area in Canada, and third largest on the West Coast. It’s a major hub for international trade, with one of the largest ports in the world, giving it a large migrant population, mainly from Asia, the Middle East, and Australia. It’s also been a long-time home to the Canadian film industry, and has even been nicknamed “North Hollywood.” Dozens of film and television productions from major studios film here every year.
Vancouver is very much an international city. It has large boroughs dedicated to varying cultures, including one of the largest Chinatowns in the world. The society here is more receptive to new ideas, always looking for the next big thing; it’s not surprising that floating has blown up in Vancouver as much as it has.
In the last 3 years, 10 float centers have opened up, most of them being larger 4–6 tank centers. The really interesting thing is how they all opened within the same short amount of time about 1 ½ to 2 years ago, within months of each other.
The Float Tour Blog – Issue #25
We finally made it back to the West Coast! We went through the Canadian Rockies and were overwhelmed by the beauty of it all. We drove through hours and hours of winding mountain roads, fertile valleys, and tiny towns so picturesque they looked like movie sets. It was so captivating, in fact, I suspect Graham and Ashkahn may have secretly replaced themselves with robotic doppelgängers to hike throughout Banff.
This post will focus on the smaller communities in B.C. that are bringing floating to new people every day. We also get to visit Canadian manufacturer Pro Float. They’re relatively new to the scene, just opening up earlier this year – another exciting sign of the growth in the industry.
